Why Aren’t More Wineries Using Climate-Friendly Bottles?

  • |

Earlier this year at a dinner with many witnesses, I pledged to do something more to help fight climate change. I blame the Napa RISE organizers and the dinner hosts, JeanCharles Boisset and Gina Gallo, for this moment of clarity.

What I did afterward was start a personal research project. It’s on an aspect of wine production that has been identified as the biggest target wineries can aim at to reduce their carbon footprints and thus reduce the amount of climate-changing gases their operations are responsible for releasing into our ever-warmer atmosphere.

I began weighing all the 750 ml. bottles of wine that Napa and Sonoma wineries sent me to review in blind tastings once they were empty. What I’ve found so far is dramatic. Having weighed 709 wines since May, my data show the average weight is 660 grams or 1 lb. 7 ounces. That is not bad, compared to the heaviest bottles, which weighed almost twice that: more than 1,200 grams or nearing 2 lbs. 11 ounces.

But 660 grams is still a lot heavier than it needs to be. An impressive 102 bottles came in under 500 grams, showing that it’s feasible to use lightweight, climate-friendly bottles and not go out of business.

You May Also Like: How Sustainable is ‘Green’ Wine Packaging?

The featherweight champs included familiar names like Bouchaine, Gundlach Bundschu, Grgich Hills, Charles Krug, La Crema and Silverado, as well as boutique outfits like Joseph Jewell and Complant. Patent Sauvignon Blanc was the only bottle so far that clocked in under 400 grams.

The lightest bottles tended to carry the lightest types of wine—Sauvignon Blanc, rosé, one Vermentino. All the heaviest bottles, those over 1,000 grams, housed— no surprise—full-bodied and tannic Cabernet Sauvignons and Bordeaux-style red blends.

Those heavy bottles cost more for wineries to buy, more to ship out, put more physical demands on winery workers who schlep cases from the bottling line to stack on pallets, more effort for delivery drivers, sommeliers and store clerks, plus they don’t fit on many store shelves and wine racks.

Adding in the weight of the wine itself, a case of the heaviest Cabernet in my study weighs 51 lbs., while a case of lighter-weight bottles of Cabernet by a brand like Elizabeth Spencer or Greg Norman only weighs 32 lbs. The difference is vast.

And the difference represents vastly more fossil fuels to produce the heavier bottles, to ship the bottles to wineries and then from wineries to distributors when full. It makes a significant difference in a winery’s carbon footprint to go to lighter glass. This in turn means less carbon dioxide is being sent up into the sky, which goes toward slowing global warming and all the catastrophes it is already causing.

So why don’t more wineries go there? Are lighter bottles not available?

“Dozens of choices are available,” says Rich Bouwer, CEO of Free Flow Wines in Sonoma, a speaker at Napa RISE and a former winery and wine bottle company exec. “If you’re above 800 grams per bottle you are not trying. What it’s about is that brand position is more important than the carbon footprint.”

Take a Deeper Dive: Wineries Strive for Carbon Neutrality. Is It Enough?

A deep-seated misperception exists that a heavier bottle means a higher quality wine that deserves a higher price. Or does it? Marketing experts say that younger consumers value transparency, low-intervention practices, organic and sustainability credentials. Hefty glass would seem anathema to that.

“We’re going to teach the consumers that lighter weight is a good thing,” says Katie Leonardini at Whitehall Lane Winery in Napa Valley. “To be sustainable means having a smaller carbon footprint and that’s good for everyone.”

Of course, you don’t have to wait. I hope that the next time you pick up an especially heavy bottle in a wine shop or liquor store, your decision to buy or not to buy is carefully weighed.

This article originally appeared in the November 2023 issue of Wine Enthusiast magazine. Click here to subscribe today!

To see a full list of members visit: napagreen.org/participating-members

About napa green

About Napa Green: The Napa Green 501c3 is a global leader in sustainable winegrowing, setting the highest bar for sustainability and climate action in the wine industry. Napa Green facilitates whole system soil to bottle certification for wineries and vineyards, and provides the expertise, boots-on-the-ground support, and resources to continually improve. Learn more at https://napagreen.org/participating-members/.

Anna Brittain
Napa Green
+1 805-636-3329
email us here
Visit us on social media:
Facebook
LinkedIn
Instagram

napagreen

758

From soil to bottle - the leading sustainable wine growing certification program for Napa County Vineyards & Wineries.
Follow @risewinesymposium

‼️ Save this Itinerary ‼️

@mvino1 has spent her career in the wine business telling the unique stories of wineries and as a Sommelier and Vintner. Here she has created an itinerary that showcases a rich variety of regional efforts in the Stag’s Leap District, Oakville and northern St. Helena. Check it out to experience the whole systems, regenerative practices at each of these @napagreen certified wineries that are as essential and unique as the terroir we pride ourselves on here in Napa Valley.

📍 @chimneyrockwinery
📍 @bcellars
📍 @boeschenvineyards

Visit these wineries to create deep meaningful connections and support local, sustainable businesses. Check out our climate smart itineraries - you really can’t go wrong.

#winetasting #sustainablewine #winetastingitinerary

Open post by napagreen with ID 18424855471113889
‼️ Save this Itinerary ‼️ @mvino1 has spent her career in the wine business telling the unique stories of wineries and as a Sommelier and Vintner. Here she has created an itinerary that showcases a rich variety of regional efforts in the Stag’s Leap District, Oakville and northern St. Helena. Check it out to experience the whole systems, regenerative practices at each of these @napagreen certified wineries that are as essential and unique as the terroir we pride ourselves on here in Napa Valley. 📍 @chimneyrockwinery 📍 @bcellars 📍 @boeschenvineyards Visit these wineries to create deep meaningful connections and support local, sustainable businesses. Check out our climate smart itineraries - you really can’t go wrong. #winetasting #sustainablewine #winetastingitinerary
31 1

We love working with @mcecleanenergy to not only help you save energy but also money!

Hear from Dominus Estate’s Tod Mostero to hear how much they saved from a lighting change then connect with the Napa Green or MCE team to learn more.

🎥 @robot_productions

#energyefficiency #climateaction #sustainablebusiness #greenbusiness #sustainablewine

Open post by napagreen with ID 18150775828437600
We love working with @mcecleanenergy to not only help you save energy but also money! Hear from Dominus Estate’s Tod Mostero to hear how much they saved from a lighting change then connect with the Napa Green or MCE team to learn more. 🎥 @robot_productions #energyefficiency #climateaction #sustainablebusiness #greenbusiness #sustainablewine
22 3

‼️Save this Itinerary‼️

Check out these stunning @napagreen certified wineries in this itinerary from @evyncam that takes you from the bay to the forest to explore the wide range of ecosystems that Napa Valley has to explore.

📍 @bouchaine_vineyards
📍 @ruddestate
📍 @seaveyvineyard

Visit these wineries to create deep meaningful connections and support local, sustainable businesses. Check out our climate smart itineraries - you really can’t go wrong.

#winetasting #sustainablewine #winetastingitinerary

Open post by napagreen with ID 18248810245288109
‼️Save this Itinerary‼️ Check out these stunning @napagreen certified wineries in this itinerary from @evyncam that takes you from the bay to the forest to explore the wide range of ecosystems that Napa Valley has to explore. 📍 @bouchaine_vineyards 📍 @ruddestate 📍 @seaveyvineyard Visit these wineries to create deep meaningful connections and support local, sustainable businesses. Check out our climate smart itineraries - you really can’t go wrong. #winetasting #sustainablewine #winetastingitinerary
53 3

Find out what being @napagreen certified means to @joshwidaman and the team @pineridgewine, then go for a visit and taste the love in every bottle!

#sustainablewine #regenerativeviticulture #winetasting

Open post by napagreen with ID 18054864959363298
Find out what being @napagreen certified means to @joshwidaman and the team @pineridgewine, then go for a visit and taste the love in every bottle! #sustainablewine #regenerativeviticulture #winetasting
49 2

‼️ Save this Itinerary ‼️

Check out this itinerary by @danpetroski of participating @napagreen wineries and vineyards that contribute to the long-term health of our land and ensure that Napa Valley remains a thriving and beautiful region for future generations.

📍 @larkmeadvineyards
📍 @silveroakcellars
📍 @vsattui

Looking for holiday experiences that create deep meaningful connections and support local, sustainable businesses? Check out our climate smart itineraries - you really can’t go wrong.

#winetasting #sustainablewine #winetastingitinerary

Open post by napagreen with ID 17910541287274704
‼️ Save this Itinerary ‼️ Check out this itinerary by @danpetroski of participating @napagreen wineries and vineyards that contribute to the long-term health of our land and ensure that Napa Valley remains a thriving and beautiful region for future generations. 📍 @larkmeadvineyards 📍 @silveroakcellars 📍 @vsattui Looking for holiday experiences that create deep meaningful connections and support local, sustainable businesses? Check out our climate smart itineraries - you really can’t go wrong. #winetasting #sustainablewine #winetastingitinerary
8 1

‼️ Save this Itinerary ‼️

This is not your typical itinerary by @abrittain – wetting your palate for wine producers that are difficult, perhaps impossible, to visit. However, if you are a wine connoisseur seeking exceptional wines from sustainability and climate leaders you should absolutely put in the effort to secure wines from these @napagreen certified producers.

📍 @dominusestatewinery
📍 @lailvineyards
📍 @adamvs

Looking for holiday experiences that create deep meaningful connections and support local, sustainable businesses? Check out our climate smart itineraries - you really can’t go wrong.

#winetasting #sustainablewine #winetastingitinerary

Open post by napagreen with ID 18085815553863954
‼️ Save this Itinerary ‼️ This is not your typical itinerary by @abrittain – wetting your palate for wine producers that are difficult, perhaps impossible, to visit. However, if you are a wine connoisseur seeking exceptional wines from sustainability and climate leaders you should absolutely put in the effort to secure wines from these @napagreen certified producers. 📍 @dominusestatewinery 📍 @lailvineyards 📍 @adamvs Looking for holiday experiences that create deep meaningful connections and support local, sustainable businesses? Check out our climate smart itineraries - you really can’t go wrong. #winetasting #sustainablewine #winetastingitinerary
20 1

‼️Save this Itinerary ‼️

This itinerary is ideal for a girls’ trip or a day out with friends! Discover the sustainable side of Napa with @goodfriendsgoodfood itinerary, which celebrates diversity and offers wines tailored to a range of palates.

These @napagreen certified wineries provide beautiful settings to connect over fantastic wine, all while supporting positive change within the wine industry.

📍 @domainecarneros
📍 @rdwinery
📍 @trefethenfamily

Looking for holiday experiences that create deep meaningful connections and support local, sustainable businesses? Check out our climate smart itineraries - you really can’t go wrong.

#winetasting #sustainablewine #winetastingitinerary

Open post by napagreen with ID 18084091499105010
‼️Save this Itinerary ‼️ This itinerary is ideal for a girls’ trip or a day out with friends! Discover the sustainable side of Napa with @goodfriendsgoodfood itinerary, which celebrates diversity and offers wines tailored to a range of palates. These @napagreen certified wineries provide beautiful settings to connect over fantastic wine, all while supporting positive change within the wine industry. 📍 @domainecarneros 📍 @rdwinery 📍 @trefethenfamily Looking for holiday experiences that create deep meaningful connections and support local, sustainable businesses? Check out our climate smart itineraries - you really can’t go wrong. #winetasting #sustainablewine #winetastingitinerary
20 1

‼️ Save this itinerary‼️

This itinerary by Sommelier and Vintner, @danpetroski, showcases a rich variety of regional efforts from @napagreen certified wineries with a diversity of style, size, production and profiles, where each place focuses on varies in accordance with their distinct microclimate.

Be sure to check out the second 1/2 of this itinerary to complete your visit!

📍 @ashesxdiamonds
📍 @cliffledevineyards
📍 @hydewines

Looking for holiday experiences that create deep meaningful connections and support local, sustainable businesses? Check out our climate smart itineraries - you really can’t go wrong.

#winetasting #sustainablewine #winetastingitinerary

Open post by napagreen with ID 18090316288948078
‼️ Save this itinerary‼️ This itinerary by Sommelier and Vintner, @danpetroski, showcases a rich variety of regional efforts from @napagreen certified wineries with a diversity of style, size, production and profiles, where each place focuses on varies in accordance with their distinct microclimate. Be sure to check out the second 1/2 of this itinerary to complete your visit! 📍 @ashesxdiamonds 📍 @cliffledevineyards 📍 @hydewines Looking for holiday experiences that create deep meaningful connections and support local, sustainable businesses? Check out our climate smart itineraries - you really can’t go wrong. #winetasting #sustainablewine #winetastingitinerary
20 0

@closduval’s bottles from Verallia are 30% lighter than traditional bottles, which represents a 34% reduction in carbon emissions from glass production alone!

Lightweight glass saves natural resources, lowers transportation costs and emissions, and reduces the risk of employee injuries. Not only is it infinitely recyclable, it’s also beautiful!

Get a bottle (or several) of this @napagreen certified wine to feel and taste the commitment sustainability from soil to bottle.

#winetasting #wineindustry #climateaction #lightenup #lightweightglassbottles

Open post by napagreen with ID 18087758179966193
@closduval’s bottles from Verallia are 30% lighter than traditional bottles, which represents a 34% reduction in carbon emissions from glass production alone! Lightweight glass saves natural resources, lowers transportation costs and emissions, and reduces the risk of employee injuries. Not only is it infinitely recyclable, it’s also beautiful! Get a bottle (or several) of this @napagreen certified wine to feel and taste the commitment sustainability from soil to bottle. #winetasting #wineindustry #climateaction #lightenup #lightweightglassbottles
17 2

‼️ Save this Itinerary‼️

Get insider information and tips to make the most of your trip to some of @reyeswine.mw’s favorite Napa Green certified wineries with this exclusive in-the-know Itinerary.

📍 @rdwinery
📍 @sequoiagrove
📍 @schramsberg

Looking for holiday experiences that create deep meaningful connections and support local, sustainable businesses? Check out our climate smart itineraries - you really can’t go wrong.

#winetasting #sustainablewine #winetastingitinerary

Open post by napagreen with ID 17981751440937271
‼️ Save this Itinerary‼️ Get insider information and tips to make the most of your trip to some of @reyeswine.mw’s favorite Napa Green certified wineries with this exclusive in-the-know Itinerary. 📍 @rdwinery 📍 @sequoiagrove 📍 @schramsberg Looking for holiday experiences that create deep meaningful connections and support local, sustainable businesses? Check out our climate smart itineraries - you really can’t go wrong. #winetasting #sustainablewine #winetastingitinerary
37 1

‼️Save this Itinerary‼️

This itinerary, by Master Sommelier, @andrearobinsonms, will take you to @napagreen Certified wineries, where we can see and taste the commitment to our planet and our community that pays off now in great wine, natural beauty and soil health, while paying it forward.

📍 @chandonusa
📍 @grgichhillsestate @grgichhills
📍 @troisnoixwine

Looking for holiday experiences that create deep meaningful connections and support local, sustainable businesses? Check out our climate smart itineraries - you really can’t go wrong.

#winetasting #sustainablewine #winetastingitinerary

Open post by napagreen with ID 18031500425761763
‼️Save this Itinerary‼️ This itinerary, by Master Sommelier, @andrearobinsonms, will take you to @napagreen Certified wineries, where we can see and taste the commitment to our planet and our community that pays off now in great wine, natural beauty and soil health, while paying it forward. 📍 @chandonusa 📍 @grgichhillsestate @grgichhills 📍 @troisnoixwine Looking for holiday experiences that create deep meaningful connections and support local, sustainable businesses? Check out our climate smart itineraries - you really can’t go wrong. #winetasting #sustainablewine #winetastingitinerary
21 3

Congratulations to @twentyrowswines for @napagreen Winery Certification!

Twenty Rows crafts small lots of their Napa Valley wines, at the @fiordisolewines certified sustainable facility. These wines are not only made with environmental impact in mind, they reflect honest varietal character and showcase the terroir where the grapes were grown.

#sustainablewine #sustainablewinery #napavalleywine

Open post by napagreen with ID 17930563980140012
Congratulations to @twentyrowswines for @napagreen Winery Certification! Twenty Rows crafts small lots of their Napa Valley wines, at the @fiordisolewines certified sustainable facility. These wines are not only made with environmental impact in mind, they reflect honest varietal character and showcase the terroir where the grapes were grown. #sustainablewine #sustainablewinery #napavalleywine
27 1

‼️ Save this Itinerary! ‼️

This itinerary by @abrittain will take you to @napagreen certified, tucked away spots, run by some powerhouse women, deeply dedicated to the stewardship of the Napa Valley.

📍 @tressabores
📍 @viadernapavalley
📍 @spottswoodewinery

Looking for holiday experiences that create deep meaningful connections and support local, sustainable businesses? Check out our climate smart itineraries - you really can’t go wrong.

#winetasting #sustainablewine #winetastingitinerary

Open post by napagreen with ID 18070192238099610
‼️ Save this Itinerary! ‼️ This itinerary by @abrittain will take you to @napagreen certified, tucked away spots, run by some powerhouse women, deeply dedicated to the stewardship of the Napa Valley. 📍 @tressabores 📍 @viadernapavalley 📍 @spottswoodewinery Looking for holiday experiences that create deep meaningful connections and support local, sustainable businesses? Check out our climate smart itineraries - you really can’t go wrong. #winetasting #sustainablewine #winetastingitinerary
17 1
This error message is only visible to WordPress admins
Error: There is no connected business account for the user .